There’s a particular feeling that settles over St Francis Bay as December approaches. The holidaymakers start arriving, the braai fires are lit a little earlier each evening, and conversations drift easily from the year that was to the one ahead. It’s one of my favourite times of the year.
It is also, I’ve noticed over more than thirty years of doing this work, the season when I most often hear a sentence that makes me sit up a little straighter: “Dirk, a friend told me about this wonderful opportunity…”
Usually, it’s nothing to worry about. But every now and then, what follows is a Ponzi scheme wrapped in festive paper. So, before the season gets into full swing, I’d like to share a few gentle thoughts on how to recognise one, and how to keep your hard-earned savings safe.
![]()
An old trick in a new coat
The scheme takes its name from Charles Ponzi, who in 1920 persuaded thousands of people in Boston that he could make them rich trading international postal coupons. In truth, he was simply paying his early investors with money from the later ones. It worked beautifully, right up until the new money stopped coming in.
A hundred years on, the structure hasn’t changed at all. Only the costume has. Today it tends to arrive via WhatsApp, dressed up as crypto, forex trading or some clever “system” that only a few insiders know about. Here in South Africa, we’ve seen this play out painfully close to home, with the collapse of Mirror Trading International leaving many ordinary families poorer and wiser.
Why the festive season?
December is expensive. There are gifts to buy, travel to pay for, and January’s school fees and bills waiting patiently around the corner. When money feels tight, a promise to double it quickly can sound less like a fairy tale and more like an answer.
We’re also quite rightly a little more relaxed at this time of year. We’re on holiday, we’re distracted, and the last thing we feel like doing between the turkey and the cricket is reading the fine print. Those running these schemes know this, and they rely on it.
It usually comes through people we trust
This is the part I find hardest. A Ponzi scheme seldom arrives from a stranger. It comes from a brother-in-law at the braai, a golfing partner, someone from church or a neighbour down the road. And here’s the thing: the person telling you about it is often completely sincere. They’ve genuinely been paid, so their enthusiasm is real.
That’s exactly how these schemes spread so quickly through close-knit communities like ours. And when they collapse, as they always do, it isn’t only money that’s lost. Friendships and family relationships often go with it.
The signs I look for
Over the years, I’ve found the warning signs are remarkably consistent:
• Returns that are high and steady, no matter what markets are doing. Real investments wobble. If something never has a bad month, that’s not reassuring. It’s a red flag.
• Big rewards with “no risk”. Risk and return always travel together. Anyone telling you otherwise is selling something.
• Pressure to decide quickly. “The window closes at the end of December” is a sales line, not an investment principle.
• A vague explanation of how the money is made. If it can’t be explained simply, there’s usually a reason.
• Incentives to bring in friends and family. Genuine investments don’t need you to recruit.
• Difficulty getting your money out. Delays, excuses and new “fees” when you ask to withdraw are often the beginning of the end.
A few simple safeguards
None of this requires you to become an expert. A little calm common sense goes a very long way:
• Check the credentials. Anyone offering financial products in South Africa should be an authorised financial services provider. You can look them up on the Financial Sector Conduct Authority’s (FSCA) website in a few minutes.
• Ask how it makes money and listen carefully to the answer. If you don’t understand it, it’s perfectly fine to say no.
• Sleep on it. No legitimate investment disappears because you took a week over Christmas to think it through.
• Talk to someone independent. Your financial planner, or a trusted adviser who has nothing to gain from your decision, is a good sounding board. That’s what we’re here for.
• If something feels wrong, report it. A quick word to the FSCA can protect your neighbours, your friends, and the next person who hears that same enticing sentence.
A quieter kind of wealth
I’ve always believed that real wealth is built slowly, quietly and frankly, a little boringly. It’s the result of sensible decisions made consistently over many years, not a single lucky break over the holidays.
So, this festive season, by all means be generous with your time, your laughter and your hospitality. Just be a little more careful with your savings. The old saying still holds true: if it sounds too good to be true, it almost certainly is.
—
Dirk Groeneveld, Certified Financial Planner
t. 083 261 9287
e. dirk@clientcare.co.za
Recent Columns
Beware the Fear Mongers When Investing
Living the Best Retirement May Mean Putting the Cart Before the Horse
What This Week Reminded Me About My Work
The Soft Stuff Is the Hard Stuff
—
Disclaimer:This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute financial advice in any way or form. It is important to consult a financial planner to receive financial advice before acting on any information contained herein. Client Care and PWM and its directors, officers, and employees shall not be responsible and disclaim all liability for any loss, damage (whether direct, indirect, special or consequential) and/or expense of any nature whatsoever, which may be suffered as a result of, or which may be attributable, directly or indirectly, to the use of, or reliance upon any information contained in this article.






Recent Comments